Josh

1. Tomas in The Orphanage
2. Count Orlok, Nosferatu
3. The clown, Poltergeist
4. The Skeksis, The Dark Crystal
5. Sadako, Ringu

Michael Phillips

1. Norman Bates, Psycho
   
2. Bob Vaughn, Zodiac
3. Mirador Motel Night Manager, Touch of Evil
   
4. Frank Booth, Blue Velvet
5. Dr. David Kibner, Invasion of the Body Snatchers (1978)